Library

Notes: Progression to clinical liver failure has been observed in hepatitis C (HCV)-infected, HIV-seropositive haemophiliacs. We studied the records of 176 haemophiliacs who were infected with HIV and/or HCV seen between 1980 and 1993. Thirty-two of 113 (28%) HIV-seropositive patients died during the study period. Ten of these patients died of liver failure, representing 31% of all mortality. An additional four HIV-seropositive patients who died of other causes had end-stage liver disease. Clinical liver failure occurred in 12% of the HIV-infected cohort. None of the HIV-seronegative, HCV-infected patients suffered from liver failure. Among HIV-infected patients, liver failure was associated with advanced age and decreased CD4 counts. Severe, sporadic ALT elevations were associated with liver failure; persistent transaminase elevations were associated with mortality. We conclude that HIV infection enhances progression of HCV infection to clinical liver failure, and that liver failure is a major cause of mortality in HIV-positive haemophiliacs.

Notes: Summary.  Liver biopsy plays a pivotal role in the management of patients with a variety of liver diseases, including chronic hepatitis C virus. The major risk of the procedure is the potential for significant haemorrhagic complications. Although the data are limited, the procedure does not appear to pose excessive risk to the patient with inherited disorders of coagulation, provided that adequate haemostasis can be achieved prior to the liver biopsy. This requires close coordination of care between the hepatologist and the haematologist. Indications for liver biopsy should be the same in patients with haemophilia as in other populations.

Notes: Summary. Diagnosis and therapy for the vast majority of haemophiliacs in the world remain beyond their reach. Health care costs for hemophilia replacement products keep rising. Global inequities for financing health care result in most hemophiliacs being undertreated. The transfusion-transmitted disease, factor VIII inhibitors, is common. Its predictability escapes detection. Management has progressed substantially and offers many therapeutic modalities. Programs for prophylaxis or immune tolerance induction are impossible for most patients. Thus, the challenge for haemophiliacs is to attain these goals.

Notes: Summary.  The impact on the cost of care for haemophilia patients with inhibitors is not well defined. To quantify the effect on health care expenditures associated with inhibitors to factor VIII (FVIII) or FIX, we conducted a retrospective cohort study examining product use and outcomes in adult and paediatric haemophilia patients with and without inhibitors. Twelve patients with inhibitors to FVIII or FIX (cases) identified in the haemophilia surveillance system (HSS) at two centres were matched on age, severity of haemophilia, and treatment centre to haemophilia patients without inhibitors. Patients with HIV or significant liver disease were excluded from the study. All eligible non-inhibitor control patients were selected for inclusion in the study, resulting in a total of 28 controls. We then tracked product usage and hospitalizations from programme entry until 1998 or loss to follow-up, producing a total database of 184 person-years of experience. A descriptive matched analysis was conducted to examine annual differences in the cost of product used and hospitalizations. We found that the median cost for factor products among haemophilia patients with inhibitors was $55 853/year, $2760 less than comparable haemophilia patients without inhibitors. The median number of hospitalizations per year was 1.0 for both inhibitor and non-inhibitor patients and the median number of days hospitalized was virtually the same. Although these findings do not appear to support the belief that there is a substantial increase in the cost of care for haemophilia patients with inhibitors, it does document that a few outlier patients can drive the cost of treatment for this disease. As the largest component of the cost of care is that of factor concentrate, it becomes imperative in the current health care environment to better define the true costs and benefits of treatments designed to eradicate or manage inhibitors. A careful cost accounting of immune tolerance induction (ITI) and other therapeutic strategies, taking into account successes and failures and duration and intensity of therapy, should help to better define the costs and benefits of such approaches. Methods to identify high cost inhibitor patients should be developed so that these strategies may be targeted to appropriate candidates.

Notes: Summary.  Historically, the leading cause of death among persons with haemophilia and other congenital coagulation disorders was uncontrolled bleeding. Mortality was associated with severe deficiency of coagulation factors VIII or IX and especially with high-titre antifactor neutralizing antibodies (inhibitors). The catastrophic contamination of plasma donor pools with human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) resulted in acquired immunodeficiency syndrome replacing haemorrhage as the leading cause of death among persons with haemophilia. Rather little has been written, however, about mortality among those not infected with HIV. The objective of this study was to identify conditions associated with all-cause mortality among HIV-uninfected patients who were followed for a mean of 8.8 years in the Multicentre Hemophilia Cohort Study. Among the 364 children (mean age 8 years), there were four deaths; two related to cancer, one to trauma, and the fourth to haemorrhage, end-stage liver disease and sepsis. Among the 387 HIV-uninfected adults (mean age 35 years) there were 29 deaths, with haemorrhage the leading cause of death, followed by hepatic, stroke and cancer deaths. Prognostic factors for all-cause mortality among the adults included haemophilia Type A with neutralizing antibodies [age-adjusted relative rate (RR) 3.1, 95% confidence interval (CI) 1.4–6.9] and serologic evidence of both hepatitis B and C virus (RR 4.1, 95% CI 0.97–17.6). Although hepatitis C viral load was slightly lower in patients with hepatitis B virus surface antigenaemia, it was unrelated to vital status. We conclude that causes of death and prognostic factors for current HIV-uninfected haemophilia patients are similar to those noted before the HIV epidemic. Better understanding, prevention and control of neutralizing antibodies and hepatitis infections may substantially improve longevity for people with haemophilia.