Abstract
Scientific quality in a technical policy document is defined in terms of the proportion of contemporary scientific principles on a subject that the document competently discusses. As a case study of the scientific quality of such documents, this articles examines the treatment of acid deposition effects in 126 environmental impact statements on fossil-fuel power plants. On average, the relevant environmental statements cover only a quarter of the eligible scientific principles. Bureaucratic and political factors influence the quality of discussion of acid deposition more than do strictly objective or scientific factors. In particular, public participation and interagency review processes foster relatively thorough consideration of scientific information in environmental impact statements.
Similar content being viewed by others
Literature cited
Ambio, 1972. Sulphur pollution across national boundaries.Ambio 1:15–20.
Ames, M. E. 1978. Outcome uncertain: science and the political process. Communications Press, Washington, DC.
Andrews, R. N. L. 1976a. Agency responses to NEPA: a comparison and implications.Natural Resources Journal 16:301–322.
Andrews, R. N. L. 1976b. Environmental policy and administrative change. D. C. Heath, Lexington, MA.
Beamish, R. J., and H. H. Harvey. 1972. Acidification of the La Cloche Mountain lakes, Ontario, and resulting fish mortalities.Journal of the Fisheries Research Board of Canada 29:1131–1143.
Caldwell, L. 1982. Science and the National Environmental Policy Act. University of Alabama Press, University, AL.
Canter, L. 1977. Environmental impact assessment. McGraw-Hill, New York.
Carter, L. J. 1976. National Environmental Policy Act: critics say promise unfulfilled.Science 193:130–132.
Council on Environmental Quality. 1973. Environmental quality—1973. Government Printing Office, Washington, DC.
Council on Environmental Quality. 1978. National Environmental Policy Act: interpretation of procedural provisions, final regulations.Federal Register 43:55978–56007.
Cowling, E. B. 1982. Acid precipitation in historical perspective.Environmental Science and Technology 16:110A-117A.
Cronan, C. S., and C. L. Schofield. 1979. Aluminum leaching response to acid precipitation: effects on high-elevated watersheds in the northeast.Science 204:304–306.
Culhane, P., R. Liroff, S. Fairfax. 1978. Letters to the editor.Science 202:1034–1038.
Dochinger, L. S., and T. A. Seliga (eds.). 1976. Proceedings of the first international symposium on acid precipitation and the forest ecosystem, 12–15 May 1975. US Forest Service, Northeastern Forest Experiment Station, Columbus, OH.
Driscoll, C. T., J. P. Baker, J. T. Biscogni, and C. L. Schofield. 1980. Effect of aluminum speciation on fish in dilute acidified waters.Nature 284:161–164.
Environmental Defense Fund v.Corps of Engineers [Gillham Dam]. 1972. 470Federal Reporter, 2nd series 289; 342Federal Supplement 1211.
Environmental Protection Agency. 1979. Acid rain: a research summary. Environmental Protection Agency, Office of Research and Development, Washington, DC.
Fairfax, J. A. W., and J. W. Lepp. 1975. Effect of simulated acid rain on cation loss from leaves.Nature 255:324–325.
Fairfax, S. 1978. A disaster in the environmental movement.Science 199:743–748.
Fairfax, S., and B. Andrews. 1979. Debate within and debate without: NEPA and the redefinition of the “prudent man” rule.Natural Resources Journal 19:505–536.
Ferenbaugh, R. W., and D. E. Bilderbach. 1974. The effects of simulated acid rain onPhaseolus vulgaris.American Journal of Botany (Suppl. 5) 61:28.
Friesema, H. P., and P. Culhane. 1976. Social impacts, politics, and the environmental impact statement process.Natural Resources Journal 16:339–356.
Galloway, J. N., and E. B. Cowling. 1978. The effects of precipitation on aquatic and terrestrial ecosystems: a proposed precipitation chemistry network.APCA Journal 28:229–235.
Galloway, N. J., G. E. Likens, and E. S. Edgerton. 1976. Acid precipitation in the northeastern U.S.Science 194:722–724.
Gorham, E. 1958. Free acid in British soils.Nature 181:106.
Gorham, E., and A. Gordon. 1960. The influence of smelter fumes upon the chemical composition of lake waters near Sudbury, Ontario, and upon surrounding vegetation.Canadian Journal of Botany 38:477–487.
Haitovsky, Y. 1969. A note on the maximization of ¯R 2.American Statistician 23:20–21.
Harvey, H. H. 1979. The acid deposition problem and emerging research needs in the toxicity of fishes.In Proceedings of the fifth annual aquatic toxicity workshop, Hamilton, Ontario, 7–9 November 1978.Fisheries and Marine Service Technical Report 862:115–128.
International Atlantic Salmon Foundation. 1981. Proceedings of the conference on acid rain and Atlantic salmon. International Atlantic Salmon Foundation, special publication series no. 10.
Kerr, R. A. 1982. Tracing sources of acid rain causes big stir.Science 215:881.
Leivestad, H., and I. P. Munoz. 1976. Fish kill at low pH in a Norwegian river.Nature 259:391–392.
Lewis-Beck, M. S. 1980. Applied regression. Quantitative applications in the social sciences no. 22. Sage, Beverly Hills, CA.
Likens, G. E., and F. H. Bormann. 1974. Acid rain: a serious regional environmental problem.Science 184:1176–1179.
Likens, G. E., F. H. Bormann, and N. M. Johnson. 1972. Acid rain.Environment 14:33–40.
Liroff, R. 1976. A national policy for the environment: NEPA and its aftermath. Indiana University Press, Bloomington, IN.
Marshall, E. 1982. Air pollution clouds U.S.-Canadian relations.Science 217:1118–1119.
Menendez, R. 1976. Chronic effects of reduced pH on brook trout.Journal of the Fisheries Research Board of Canada 33:118–123.
Nelkin, D. (ed.). 1979. Controversy: politics of technical decisions. Sage, Beverly Hills, CA.
Peterson, R., S. Auerbach, R. Brochsen, R. Craig, F. Hoffman, S. Kaye, D. Reichle, E. Struxness, C. Cowan, H. Loftin, and D. Schindler. 1976. Editorial and letters to the editor.Science 193:188, 193, 248, and 251.
Rao, P., and R. Miller. 1971. Applied econometrics. Wadsworth, Belmont, CA.
Rahn, K. A. 1982. Sources of northeast pollution.Science 217:688.
Rummell, R. J. 1970. Applied factor analysis. Northwestern University Press, Evanston, IL.
Rural Electrification Administration. 1976. Apache units no. 2 and no. 3 and related transmission lines, final environmental statement. US Department of Agriculture, Rural Electrification Administration, Washington, DC, March. Applicant's environmental analysis incorporated by reference.
Schofield, C. L. 1976. Acid precipitation: effects on fish.Ambio 5:229–230.
Schindler, D. W. 1976. The impact statement boondoggle [editorial].Science 192:509.
Shriner, D. S., M. E. De Cot, and E. B. Cowling. 1974. Simulated acid precipitation causes direct injury to vegetation.Proceedings of the American Phytopathology Society 1:112.
Stanfield, R. L. 1984. Regional tensions complicate search for an acid rain remedy.National Journal 16:860–863.
Taylor, S. 1985. Making bureaucracies think: the environmental impact statement strategy of administrative reform. Stanford University Press, Stanford, CA.
Wichelman, A. 1976. Administrative agency implementation of the National Environmental Policy Act of 1969: a conceptual framework for explaining differential response.Natural Resources Journal 16:263–300.
Wolff, G. T. 1982. Acid precipitation.Science 216:1172.
Wood, T., and F. H. Bormann. 1974. The effects of an artificial mist upon the growth ofBetula allegheniensis. British Environment Pollution 7
Wood, T., and F. H. Bormann. 1975. Increases in foliar leaching caused by acidification of an artificial mist.Ambio 4:169–171.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Culhane, P.J., Armentano, T.V. & Friesema, H.P. State-of-the-art science and environmental assessments: the case of acid deposition. Environmental Management 9, 365–377 (1985). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF01866336
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF01866336