Abstract
Classical science fiction films have been depicting space voyages, aliens, trips to the moon, the sun, Mars, and other planets, known and unknown. While it is difficult to critique the depiction of fantastic places, or planets about which little was known at the time, the situation is different for the moon, about which a lot of facts were known from astronomical observations even at the turn of the century. Here we discuss the grade of realism with which the lunar surface has been depicted in a number of movies, beginning with George Méliés' 1902 classic Le Voyage dans la lune and ending, just before the first manned landing on the moon, with Stanley Kubrick's 2001: A Space Odyssey. Many of the movies present thoughtful details regarding the actual space travel (rockets), but none of the movies discussed here is entirely realistic in its portrayal of the lunar surface. The blunders range from obvious mistakes, such as the presence of a breathable atmosphere, or spiders and other lunar creatures, to the persistent vertical exaggeration of the height and roughness of lunar mountains. This is surprising, as the lunar topography was already well understood even early in the 20th century.
Article PDF
Similar content being viewed by others
Avoid common mistakes on your manuscript.
References
Agel, J. (ed.): 1970, The Making of Kubrick's 2001, Signet – The New American Library, New York, 367 pp.
Arnheim, R.: 1929, Die Frau im Mond [film review], Die Weltbühne, Berlin, No. 43, 22.10.1929.
Benson, M.: 1985, Vintage Science Fiction Films, 1896–1949, McFarland & Co., Inc., Jefferson NC, and London, 219 pp.
Bonestell, C. and Ley, W.: 1949, The Conquest of Space, Viking Press, New York, 160 pp.
Brentano B. v.: 1929, Die Gabe der sinnlichen Wahrnehmung [film review], Frankfurter Zeitung, Nr. 1776, 17.10.1929.
Eisfeld, R.: 1989, ‘Frau im Mond: Technische Vision und psychologisches Zeitbild’, in R. Eisfeld (ed.), Thea von Harbou, Frau im Mond, Heyne Verlag, Munich, pp. 207–235.
Ezra, E.: 2000, George Méliès, Manchester University Press, Manchester, 166 pp.
Geduld, C.: 1973, Filmguide to 2001: A Space Odyssey, Indiana University Press, Bloomington, 87 pp.
Geser, G.: 1999, Fritz Lang – Metropolis und die Frau im Mond, 2nd edn., Corian-Verlag, Meitingen (Germany), 193 pp.
Gregor, U. and Patalas, E.: 1976, Geschichte des Films, Vol. 1, Rowohlt, Reinbeck, Germany, 250 pp.
Harbou, T. v.: 1928, Frau im Mond, Scherl, Berlin, 230 pp.
Ihering, H.: 1929, Frau im Mond [film review], Berliner Börsen-Courier No. 484, 16.10.1929.
Lohrmann, W. G.: 1824, Topographie der sichtbaren Mondoberfläche, J. F. Hartknoch, Dresden and Leipzig, 110 pp.
Nicolson, M. H.: 1948, Voyages to the Moon, Macmillan, New York, 297 pp.
Pol, H.: 1929, Die Frau im Mond/Der neue Lang-Film [film review], Vossische Zeitung, Berlin, Nr. 489, 16.10.1929.
Rudaux, L. (1937) Sur les Autres Mondes, Libraire Larousse, Paris, 220 pp.
Strick, P.: 1976, Science Fiction Movies, Octopus Books Ltd., London, 160 pp.
Taylor, S. R.: 1982, Planetary Science: A Lunar Perspective, Lunar and Planetary Institute, Houston, 481 pp.
Wilhelms, D. E.: 1993, To a Rocky Moon – A Geologist's History of Lunar Exploration, University of Arizona Press, Tucson, 477 pp.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Jalufka, D.A., Koeberl, C. Moonstruck: How Realistic Is The Moon Depicted In Classic Science Fiction Films?. Earth, Moon, and Planets 85, 179–200 (1999). https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1017015931543
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1017015931543