Abstract
The microbial bar and pat genes confer tolerance to the non-selective herbicide phosphinothricin (PPT; sold as Basta or Finale). This tolerance in plants could provide an environmental gain compared to current-day herbicide cocktails, but the safety of such a transgene approach is questioned by many. The biosafety of the presence of these herbicide tolerance genes in plants is evaluated in a ‘transgene-centered approach’. Potentially, the introduction of transgenic PPT-tolerant crops could result in acquired PPT tolerance in weedy relatives of these crops. Assuming responsible use of this trait in agronomy, the ecological consequences with respect to weediness or spread of the transgenic PPT tolerance are concluded to be negligible. The key issue for the toxicological evaluation is whether or not the plant has actually been sprayed with PPT. Consumption of the gene and/or gene product from unsprayed transgenic plant material will not have adverse effects. In case of PPT-sprayed material, PPT or its derivatives could be present in food and feed and crop-specific metabolites might be formed. To date, the toxicological impact of such a putative exposure is not sufficiently clear, and further premarket testing is recommended.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Arias DM, Rieseberg LH: Gene flow between cultivated and wild sunflowers. Theor Appl Genet 89: 655–660 (1994).
Arriola PE: Risks of escape and spread of engineered genes from transgenic crops to wild relatives. AgBiotechnol News Info 9: 157–160 (1997).
Arriola PE, Ellstrand NC: Crop-to-weed gene flow in the genus Sorghum (Poaceae); spontaneous interspecific hybridization between johnsongrass, Sorghum halepense, and crop sorghum, S. bicolor. Am J Bot 83: 1153–1160 (1996).
Bayer E, Gugel KH, Hägele K, Hagenmaier H, Jessipow S, König WA, Zähner H: Phosphinothricin und Phosphinothricyl-Alanyl-Alanin. Helv Chim Acta 55: 224–239 (1972).
Berkowitz DB: The food safety of transgenic animals. Bio/technology 8: 819–825 (1990).
De Block M, Botterman J, Vandewiele M, Dockx J, Thoen C, Gosselé V, Rao Movva N, Thompson C, Van Montagu M, Leemans J: Engineering herbicide resistance in plants by expression of a detoxifying enzyme. EMBO J 6: 2513–2518 (1987).
Botterman J, Gosselé V, Thoen C, Lauwereys M: Characterization of phosphinothricin acetyltransferase and C-terminal enzymatically active fusion proteins. Gene 102: 33–37 (1991).
Botterman J, Leemans J: Engineering herbicide resistance in plants. Trends Genet 4: 219–221 (1988).
Crawley MJ: Arm-chair risk assessment, Bio/technology 11: 1496 (1993).
Crawley MJ: Reply on comment Miller et al. Bio/technology 12: 217 (1994).
Crawley MJ, Hails RS, Rees M, Kohn D, Buxton J: Ecology of transgenic oilseed rape in natural habitats. Nature 363: 620–623 (1993).
Devine MD, Duke SO, Fedtke C: Physiology of Herbicide Action. PTR Prentice Hall, Englewood Cliffs, NJ (1993).
Dröge W, Broer I, Pühler A: Transgenic plants containing the phosphinothricin-N-acetyltransferase gene metabolize the herbicide L-phosphinothricin (glufosinate) differently from untransformed plants. Planta 187: 142–151 (1992).
Dorn E, Görlitz G, Heusel R, Stumpf K: Verhalten von Glufosinat-ammonium in der Umwelt: Abbau im und Einfluss auf das Ökosystem. Z Pflanzenkrankh und Pflanzenschutz 13: 459–468 (1992).
Dröge-Laser W, Siemeling U, Pühler A, Broer I: The metabolites of the herbicide-phosphinothricin (glufosinate). Plant Physiol 105: 159–166 (1994).
Ebert E, Leist KH, Mayer D: Summary of safety evaluation toxicity studies of glufosinate ammonium. Food Chem Toxicol 28: 339–349 (1990).
Food and Drug Administration/Environmental Protection Agency/United States Department of Agriculture: Proceedings ‘Conference on scientific issues related to potential allergenicity in transgenic food crops’, Annapolis, MD, 18–19 April (1994).
Fredshavn JR, Poulsen GS, Huybrechts I, Rüdelsheim P: Competitiveness of transgenic oilseed rape. Transgen Res 4: 142–148 (1995).
Greef W de, Delon R, de Block M, Leemans J, Botterman J: Evaluation of herbicide resistance in transgenic crops under field conditions. Bio/technology 7: 61–64 (1989).
Hoechst: DeFinale Produktinformatie. September 1984 (1984).
Jones DD, Maryanski JH: Safety considerations in the evaluation of transgenic plants for human food. In: Levin MA and Strauss HS (eds) Risk Assessment in Genetic Engineering, pp. 64–82. McGraw-Hill, New York (1991).
Kareiva P: Transgenic plants on trial. Nature 363: 580–581 (1993).
Keeler KH: Can genetically engineered crops become weeds? Bio/technology 7: 1134–1139 (1989).
Kishore GM, Shah DM: Amino acid biosynthesis inhibitors as herbicides. Annu Rev Biochem 57: 627–663 (1988).
de Laat AAM, van Dun CMP: Inbouw van herbicideresistentiegenen in gewassen; overwegingen van een verdelingsbedrijf. Gewasbescherming 25: 179–183 (1994).
Lea PJ, Joy KW, Ramos JL, Guerrero MG: The action of the 2-amino-4-(methylphosphinyl)-butanoic acid (phosphinothricin) and its 2-oxo-derivative on the metabolism of cyanobacteria and higher plants. Phytochemistry 23: 1–6 (1984).
Lindhoud WM: HOE 39866 (Glufosinate-ammonium): state of development and prospects for the Netherlands. Med Fac Landbouwwet Rijksuniv Gent 49: 1085–1090 (1984).
Metz PLJ, Nap JP: A transgene-centered approach to the biosafety of transgenic crops: overview of selection and reporter genes. Acta Bot Neerl 46: 25–50 (1997).
Miller H, Beachy R, Huttner SL: Risk assessment redux. Bio/technology 12: 216–217 (1994).
Miller H, Huttner SL, Beachy R: Risk assessment experiments for ‘genetically modified’ plants. Bio/technology 11: 1323–1324 (1993).
Müllner H, Eckes P, Donn G: Engineering crop resistance to the naturally occurring glutamine synthetase inhibitor phosphinothricin. In: Duke SO, Menn JJ, Plimmer JR (eds) Pest Control with Enhanced Environmental Safety, pp. 38–47. ACS Symposium Series 524. American Chemical Society, Washington, DC (1993).
Murakami T, Anzai H, Imai S, Satoh A, Nagaoka K, Thompson CJ: The bialaphos biosynthetic genes of Streptomyces hygroscopicus: molecular cloning and characterization of the gene cluster. Mol Gen Genet 205: 42–50 (1986).
Nap JP, Bijvoet J, Stiekema WJ: Biosafety of kanamycin-resistant transgenic plants. Transgen Res 1: 39–249 (1992).
Rijn JP van, Straalen NM van, Willems J: Handboek bestrijdingsmiddelen: gebruik en milieueffecten. VU Uitgeverij, Amsterdam, Netherlands (1995).
Schlüter K, Fütterer J, Potrykus I: ‘Horizontal’ gene transfer from a transgenic potato line to a bacterial pathogen (Erwinia chrysanthemi) occurs –if at all– at an extremely low frequency. Bio/technology 13: 1094–1098 (1995).
Strauch E, Wohlleben W, Pühler A: Cloning of a phosphinothricin N-acetyltransferase gene from Streptomyces viridochromogenes Tü494 and its expression in Streptomyces lividans and Escherichia coli. Gene 63: 65–74 (1988).
Tachibana K, Watanabe T, Sekizuwa Y, Takematsu T: Accumulation of ammonia in plants treated with bialaphos. J Pestic Sci 11: 33–37 (1986).
Tebbe CC, Reber HH: Utilization of the herbicide phosphinothricin as a nitrogen source by soil bacteria. Appl Microbiol Biotechnol 29: 103–105 (1988).
Thompson C, Movva N, Tizard R, Crameri R, Davies J, Lauwereys M, Botterman J: Characterization of the herbicide resistance gene ‘bar’ from Streptomyces hygroscopicus. EMBO J 6: 2519–2523 (1987).
Tiedje JM, Colwell RK, Grossman YL, Hodson RE, Lenski RE, Mack RN, Regal PJ: The planned introduction of genetically engineered organisms: ecological considerations and recommendations. Ecology 70: 298–315 (1989).
Trinks K: Studies on the phosphinothricin acetyltransferase gene and protein. Mitt Biol Bundesanst 309: 49 (1995).
Walter C, Broer I, Hillemann D, Pühler A: High frequency, heat treatment-induced inactivation of the phosphinothricin resistance gene in transgenic single cell suspension cultures of Medicago sativa. Mol Gen Genet 235: 189–196 (1992).
Williamson M: Environmental risks from the release of genetically modified organisms (GMOs): the need for molecular ecology. Mol Ecol 1: 3–8 (1992).
Wohlleben W, Arnold W, Broer I, Hillemann D, Strauch E, Pühler A: Nucleotide sequence of the phosphinothricin N-acetyltransferase gene from Streptomyces viridochromogenes Tü494 and its expression in Nicotiana tabacum. Gene 70: 25–37 (1988).
WSSA (Weed Science Society of America): Herbicide Handbook, 7th ed., pp. 147–149 (1994).
Yoneyama K, Anzai H: Transgenic plants resistant to diseases by the detoxification of toxins. In: Biotechnology in Plant Disease Control, pp. 115–137. Wiley-Liss, New York (1993).
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Metz, P.L.J., Stiekema, W.J. & Nap, JP. A transgene-centered approach to the biosafety of transgenic phosphinothricin-tolerant plants. Molecular Breeding 4, 335–341 (1998). https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1009695124173
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1009695124173