Summary
At this time, there is no US legislation that is specifically aimed at regulating the environmental release of genetically engineered organisms or their modified components, either during the research and development stage or during application. There are some statutes, administered by several federal agencies, whose language is broad enough to allow the extension of intended coverage to include certain aspects of biotechnology. The one possible exception is FIFRA, which has already brought about the registration of several natural microbial pesticides but which also has provision for requiring the registration of “strain improved” microbial pesticides. Nevertheless, there may be gaps in coverage even if all pertinent statutes were to be actively applied to the control of environmental release of genetically modified substances. The decision to regulate biotechnology under TSCA was justified, in part, on the basis of its intended role as a gap-filling piece of environmental legislation. The advantage of regulating biotechnology under TSCA is that this statute, unlike others, is concerned with all media of exposure (air, water, soil, sediment, biota) that may pose health and environmental hazards. Experience may show that extending existing legislation to regulate biotechnology is a poor compromise compared to the promulgation of new legislation specifically designed for this purpose. It appears that many other countries are ultimately going to take the latter course to regulate biotechnology.
Similar content being viewed by others
Literature cited
Berg, P., D. Baltimore, H. W. Boyer, S. N. Cohen, R. W. Davis, D. S. Hogness, D. Nathans, R. Roblin, J. C. Watson, W. Weissman, and N. D. Zinder. 1974. Potential hazards of recombinant DNA molecules.Science 185:303.
Betz, F., M. Levin, and M. Rogul. 1983. Safety aspects of genetically-engineered microbial pesticides.R-DNA Technical Bulletin 6(4) (December).
Bull, A. T., G. Holt, and M. D. Lilly. 1982. Biotechnology: international trends and perspectives. Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development, 84 pp.
Clay, D. R. 1983. Statement to the US House Subcommittee on Science, Research and Technology, and Subcommittee on Investigations and Oversight, Committee on Science and Technology, 22 June.
[FFDCA] Federal Food, Drug, and Cosmetic Act. 25 June 1938, and as amended.US Code, title 21, sections 301–392.
[FIFRA] Federal Insecticide, Fungicide, and Rodenticide Act. 25 June 1947, and as amended.US Code, title 7, sections 136–136y.
[FNWA] Federal Noxious Weed Act of 1974. 3 January 1975.US Code, title 7, sections 2801–2813.
[FPPA] Federal Plant Pest Act. 23 May 1957, and as amended.US Code, title 7, sections 147a, 149, and 150aa–150jj.
Fribush, H. M. 1983. Summary of biopolymers submitted in PMNs and TMEs.In Memorandum from E. A. Klein, Director, Chemical Control Division, Office of Toxic Substances, EPA, to M. Williams, Acting Director, Office of Toxic Substances, EPA.
Lau, H. P. 1982. Memorandum to Joseph DeSantis, Chief, Policy and Program Development Branch, Chemical Control Division, Office of Toxic Substances, US EPA: Reporting of biological materials for TSCA chemical substances inventory (1 November).
[NEPA] National Environmental Policy Act of 1969. 1 January 1970, and as amended.US Code, title 42, sections 4321–4347.
[NIOSH] National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health. 29 December 1970. Public Law 91-596,Statutes at Large 84:1612.
[OSHA] Occupational Safety and Health Administration. 29 December, 1970. Public Law 91-596,Statutes at Large 84:1590.
[OECD] Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development. 1983. OECD perspective: biotechnology and government policies, safety and regulations in biotechnology.
[OPTS] Office of Pesticides and Toxic Substances. US Environmental Protection Agency. 1983. Biotechnology concerns and information needs. Draft document. Washington, DC.
[OSTP] Office of Science and Technology Policy. US Environmental Protection Agency. 1984. Proposal for a coordinated framework for regulation of biotechnology: notice.Federal Register 49:50856–50907 (31 December).
[OTA] Office of Technology Assessment. 1984. Commercial biotechnology: an international analysis. US Congress, Washington, DC, 160 pp.
[PQA] Public Quarantine Act. 20 August 1912, and as amended.US Code, title 7, sections 151–167.
[PVPA] Plant Variety Protection Act. 24 December 1920.US Code, title 7, sections 2321–2583.
River and Harbor Appropriations Act of 1899. (Also: Refuse Act of 1899.) 3 March 1899.Statutes at Large 30:1121–1161.
Singer, M., and D. Soll. 1973. Guidelines for DNA hybrid molecules.Science 181:1114.
Tooze, J. 1977. Emerging attitudes and policies in Europe. Pages 455–470in R. F. Beers, Jr., and E. G. Bassett (eds.), Recombinant molecules: impact on science and society. Raven Press, New York.
[TSCA] Toxic Substances Control Act. 11 October 1976, and as amended.US Code, title 15, sections 2601–2629.
[EPA] US Environmental Protection Agency. 1984. Microbial pesticides: interim policy on small field testing.Federal Register 49:40659–40661 (17 October).
[EPA] US Environmental Protection Agency. 1983. Subpart M: biorational pesticides. National Technical Information Service, Springfield, Virginia, PB 83-153965. Also appears in part as Data Requirements for Pesticide Registration inFederal Register 49:42900–42904 (24 October 1984).
[EPA] US Environmental Protection Agency. 1982. Pesticide registration: proposed data requirements.Federal Register 47:53192–53221 (24 November).
US Executive Order 11987. 1977. Exotic organisms.Federal Register 42:26949.
US House of Representatives, Committee on Science and Technology. 1983. Environmental implications of genetic engineering. Hearing before the Subcommittees on Investigations and Oversight and on Science, Research and Technology, 98th Congress, 1st session (22 June). Committee print no. 36, 255 pp.
Zaugg, R. H., and J. R. Swarz. 1981. Assessment of future environmental trends and problems: industrial use of applied genetics and biotechnologies. Teknekron Research, Inc., McLean, Virginia, for US Environmental Protection Agency, Office of Research and Development, Office of Exploratory Research, under EPA contract no. 68-02-3192 (EPA-600/8-81/020), 160 pp.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Stern, A.M. Regulatory aspects. Environmental Management 10, 453–462 (1986). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF01867455
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF01867455