Elsevier

The ESP Journal

Volume 1, Issue 2, Spring 1981, Pages 123-140
The ESP Journal

On the use of the passive in two astrophysics journal papers

https://doi.org/10.1016/0272-2380(81)90004-4Get rights and content

Abstract

While extensive use of the passive is shown by frequency counts of verb tense and aspect which are performed on corpora combining texts from a variety of scientific and technical fields, significantly different results may be obtained when one compares the frequency of the passive and active voices within a single scientific or technical field. In this paper we examine the frequency of the active and passive verb forms in two astrophysics journal articles, finding that we plus an active verb occurs at least as frequently as the passive in both articles. On the basis of consultation with an informant in astrophysics, we propose four rhetorical functions of the passive as opposed to we plus an active verb: (1) we indicates the author's unique procedural choice, while the passive indicates an established or standard procedure; (2) we is used to describe the author's own work and the passive to describe the work of others, unless that work is not mentioned in contrast to the author's, in which case the active is used; (3) the passive is used to describe the author's proposed studies; and (4) the use of the active or the passive is determined by focus due to the length of an element or the need for emphasis.

References (15)

  • Mahinda Cooray

    The English Passive Voice

    English Language Teaching

    (1965)
  • Libuse Duskova et al.

    A Frequency Count of English Tenses with Application to Teaching English as a Foreign Language

    Prague Studies in Mathematical Linguistics

    (1967)
  • Faith Fernalld

    A Study of the Comparative Frequency of Passive in Some College Freshman Texts

    Indian Journal of Applied Linguistics

    (1977)
  • H.V. George

    A Verb-Form Frequency Count

    English Language Teaching

    (1963)
  • John Lackstrom et al.

    Grammar and Technical English

  • Alan P. Lightman

    Time-Dependent Accretion Disks around Compact Objects. I. Theory and Basic Equations

    The Astrophysical journal

    (1974)
  • Randolph Quirk et al.

    A Grammar of Contemporary English

    (1972)
There are more references available in the full text version of this article.

Cited by (117)

  • ESP serial publications before The ESP Journal/English for Specific Purposes: Recollections and reflections of an old-timer

    2020, English for Specific Purposes
    Citation Excerpt :

    I suggest that this commonality is based, to a considerable extent, on similarities in genre across the different fields of activity, and that this gives a rough indication of the place and importance of genre in E.S.P. It has been said (by myself as well as several others) that the concept of genre was first introduced into English for Specific Purposes, independently of each other, by Swales (1981) and by Tarone, Dwyer, Gillette, and Icke (1981). It now seems that credit for the innovation really belongs to Bernard Mohan for his use of it in his 1977 TESOL presentation and subsequently published in the proceedings.

  • A three-dimensional model of personal self-mention in research papers

    2019, English for Specific Purposes
    Citation Excerpt :

    In academic writing, authors have a choice to present themselves explicitly or hide their presence. Both choices can be realized with a range of grammatical constructions: This includes, on the one hand, impersonal means (cf. Martínez, 2001), such as nominalizations, anticipatory it (e.g. Hewings & Hewings, 2002), inanimate subjects (e.g. Master, 1991), and passive constructions (e.g. Tarone, Dwyer, Gillette, & Icke, 1981), and on the other hand, first person singular pronouns, first person plural pronouns (both reader-exclusive and reader-inclusive), self-reference words such as the author(s) or the researcher(s), and sometimes even the third person pronouns to refer to the authors’ own previous published work (Kuo, 1999; Pho, 2008). While writers typically use a number of these options in the same paper, their preference for certain means and avoidance of others reveals their affiliation with a particular social group (Ivanič & Camps, 2001).

  • Strengthening move analysis methodology towards bridging the function-form gap

    2018, English for Specific Purposes
    Citation Excerpt :

    Third, the identification of move boundaries (i.e. the text items signalling the beginning of a move, or the transition from one move to the next; see also Paltridge, 1994: 296) could be uncertain, but was aided by a combination of bottom-up search for lexical or syntactic signals and a top-down close reading of the text for topic breaks or shifts in content. Fourth, there was a place for specialist disciplinary experts to verify the analysts' interpretations, given their deeper knowledge of the text subject matter and their stronger intuitions regarding the typical rhetorical structure and language used in good papers in their fields (e.g. Tarone, Dwyer, Gillette, & Icke, 1981). More recently, triangulation has typically involved interviews (sometimes text-based) with various participants, very often authors, but also including editors, reviewers and expert disciplinary writers (e.g. Hyland, 2012).

View all citing articles on Scopus

Paper presented at the 1981 TESOL Convention, Detroit. We are grateful for substantive comments on the content of this paper to Kathryn Hanges, Tom Huckin, Eric Nelson, our nonymous reviewer, and many others.

View full text